'26 · '24
Woburn · MA
Pete's Roast Beef
"Two-time champion. Nobody argues this one and nobody should."
Find on App →★ 2× Champion
Pete's took the 2026 Beef Madness title in a final nobody saw coming. Plus: Peabody goes three-deep, the onion sub roll question, and why Lynn is on notice.
A crisp, buttery griddled onion roll. American cheese on the bottom. Thin-sliced rare roast beef piled high. James River BBQ sauce and mayo — that's a three-way.
It is not a deli sandwich. It is not a cheesesteak. It is its own thing — and people from Lynn to Gloucester will fight you about which spot does it best.
Six parts. One sandwich. Assembled in this exact order or it isn't a beef.
Griddled. Buttered. Crown side up. The final word.
Not Sweet Baby's. Not Bullseye. James River or the beef is forfeit.
Applied to the top roll only. It meets the BBQ mid-bite. This matters.
Sliced paper-thin. Piled high. Pink in the middle or don't bother.
On the BOTTOM. Melts up into the beef. Non-negotiable.
Onion roll. Lightly griddled. The foundation of the republic. Some spots are doing onion sub rolls now — watch that space.
Thou shalt have no other sauce before James River.
Pink in the middle. Rare. If it ain't pink, send it back.
The onion roll is the gold standard. More shops are baking their own now — custom-rolled, griddle-toasted, earned. A few are even doing onion sub rolls. The game is evolving. That credit is given, not assumed.
Cheese on the bottom. It melts up into the beef. This is not a preference. It is architecture.
Know the order before you order. Beef + cheese + BBQ + mayo = three-way. There will be a test.
Thou shalt eat it hot. Within minutes of assembly. Standing in the parking lot counts.
Kelly's invented the North Shore roast beef sandwich. Kelly's is also one of the lower-ranked spots on this list. Both are true at the same time. Handle it.
The three-way was born at Bill & Bob's. Nondas Lagonakis built it — and had a direct hand in creating James River BBQ sauce. Know where it came from.
Thin-sliced. Paper-thin. Piled high. If it looks like a deli sub, something went wrong.
This is not a trend. This is not New England's answer to anything. The North Shore didn't invent this for you. It invented it for itself.
Every reviewed spot in your pocket. Find the nearest beef, see the rating, read the verdict — wherever you are.
"Two-time champion. Nobody argues this one and nobody should."
"Rt. 125's finest. The first two-time champion. Consistent as gravity."
"Sous-vide 16 hours, sliced by hand, served Saturday only. Worth every minute."
"Hand-crafted, no shortcuts. One of Peabody's finest — and a Beef Madness champion to boot."
Every town has a spot. Here's where to start.
I ate three beefs today. One of them was at 9:30 in the morning. I have no regrets and I would do it again tomorrow.
A guy from Worcester told me his town has "beefs too." I laughed. I laughed until I cried. I'm still laughing.
The proper way to carry a beef to the car is both hands. Two hands. Always. This is not a one-hand sandwich.
If the cheese is on top it's a roast beef sandwich. A fine one, sure. But it is not a beef. Know the difference.
Major League Eating. Game On! bar. Right outside the Green Monster. North Shore Beefs will be there, and the whole country is going to know what we already know.
Be the first to know about new reviews, events, and whatever else we're cooking up.